I know a robot wrote your caption

Long story short:

  • There is nothing wrong with using AI to assist with your posts. I do it too.
  • People notice it. And automatically filter it out. It’s just noise.
  • You can still use AI to assist with your captions, but try to limit combining all of the ones below.

AI Slop. Last time I wrote about it in design. Now it’s captions. I can tell one is AI-generated before I finish the first line because I’ve been reading the same caption all week.

Here are the most obvious giveaways and what to do instead:

[All examples are AI-generated and feature fake businesses]

1. The perfectly balanced emoji (bullet) list

Instagram post for Larkspur Pilates, a fictional pilates studio, showing four matched bullets, each led by an emoji. A light-blue square annotation highlights emoji bullets.
LinkedIn post for Castellane Property Management, a fictional property management company, showing checkmark bullets of equal length. A light-blue square annotation highlights emoji bullets.
X post for Petal & Stem Florals, a fictional flower shop, showing extra sloppy: emoji numbers and an emoji on every bullet. A light-blue square annotation highlights emoji bullets.

Three to five bullets. All the same length. Each with its own emoji out front.

🎯 Set clear goals

💡 Stay curious

✅ Take consistent action

🚀 Celebrate your progress

Real lists are lumpy.

Make it extra sloppy: number them with emoji too. 1️⃣ 2️⃣ 3️⃣

Fix: If it’s a list, let it be uneven. If it’s one point, write the sentence.

2. Emoji overload

X post for Thistle & Pine Dental, a fictional dental office, showing eight emoji in two lines. A light-blue square annotation highlights emoji overload.
Instagram post for Marigold Bakehouse, a fictional bakery, showing an emoji between every phrase. A light-blue square annotation highlights emoji overload.
LinkedIn post for Lindqvist Tax Advisory, a fictional tax firm, showing extra sloppy: one emoji after every sentence. A light-blue square annotation highlights emoji overload.

Sparkles. Rocket. Rainbow. Flexed arm. In one caption. About a dental cleaning.

Make it extra sloppy: one after every sentence.

Fix: One. And only if you’d text it to a friend that way.

3. Em dashes

LinkedIn post for Quillmark Bookkeeping, a fictional bookkeeping firm, showing four em dashes in three sentences. A light-blue square annotation highlights em dashes.
Instagram post for Salt & Cedar Spa, a fictional day spa, showing an em dash in every sentence. A light-blue square annotation highlights em dashes.
X post for Northgate Auto Repair, an fictional auto repair shop, showing four em dashes in one post. A light-blue square annotation highlights em dashes.

No explanation needed.

Fix: A period. Or a comma.

4. Short. Strong. Sentences.

LinkedIn post for Halvorsen Roofing, a fictional roofing company, showing five short lines, one per paragraph. A light-blue square annotation highlights one-line paragraphs.
Instagram post for Tideline Surf Shop, a fictional surf shop, showing every sentence isolated for emphasis. A light-blue square annotation highlights one-line paragraphs.
X post for Brightwater Financial, a fictional financial planning firm, showing extra sloppy: asks itself a question and answers it. A light-blue square annotation highlights one-line paragraphs.

Start small.

Stay focused.

Keep going.

One sentence per paragraph so every line feels important. When every line is the big line, none of them are.

Make it extra sloppy: ask yourself a question and answer it. “The little things? They become the big things.”

Fix: Write in paragraphs. The way you’d say it across the counter.

5. It’s not X. It’s Y.

LinkedIn post for Okafor Family Dentistry, a fictional dental practice, showing a made-up wrong idea, then the correction. A light-blue square annotation highlights overused contrast.
X post for Fernhill Landscaping, a fictional landscaping company, showing the same contrast on a lawn. A light-blue square annotation highlights overused contrast.
Instagram post for Iron Oak Strength, a fictional gym, showing extra sloppy: three in a row. A light-blue square annotation highlights overused contrast.

“It’s not about being perfect. It’s about being consistent.” Nobody said it was about being perfect. The robot made up a wrong opinion so it could correct it.

Make it extra sloppy: three in a row.

Fix: Delete the first half. Say the Y.

6. The manufactured revelation

LinkedIn post for Cedar & Marrow Realty, a fictional real estate brokerage, showing an epiphany with no event in it. A light-blue square annotation highlights manufactured revelation.
Instagram post for Willow & Wren Photography, a fictional portrait photographer, showing a sudden insight with no story behind it. A light-blue square annotation highlights manufactured revelation.
LinkedIn post for Estabrook Staffing, a fictional staffing agency, showing extra sloppy: the revelation is about furniture. A light-blue square annotation highlights manufactured revelation.

“I used to think success meant doing more. Then I realized it came from doing less. Everything changed.”

It’s an epiphany with no event in it.

Make it extra sloppy: have the revelation about furniture. “Moving a few desks taught us something bigger.”

Fix: If something happened, tell me what. If nothing happened, skip the epiphany.

7. The inflated opening

LinkedIn post for Beckwith & Lowe Insurance, an fictional insurance agency, showing an opening line that fits any post. A light-blue square annotation highlights inflated opening.
Instagram post for Juniper Hollow Yoga, a fictional yoga studio, showing a world-sized wind-up before a class announcement. A light-blue square annotation highlights inflated opening.
X post for Pinecrest Accounting, an fictional accounting firm, showing extra sloppy: rapidly shifting and ever-evolving. A light-blue square annotation highlights inflated opening.

“In today’s fast-paced world, connection matters more than ever.” This sentence could open a post about insurance, yoga, or a sandwich.

Make it extra sloppy: “fast-paced, ever-evolving world.”

Fix: Delete the first sentence. The post usually starts fine at the second one.

8. Forced vulnerability

Instagram post for Copperline Plumbing, a fictional plumbing company, showing a confession with nothing confessed. A light-blue square annotation highlights forced vulnerability.
LinkedIn post for Morrow & Finch Interiors, an fictional interior design studio, showing a struggle with no details. A light-blue square annotation highlights forced vulnerability.
X post for Driftwood Coffee Roasters, a fictional coffee roaster, showing extra sloppy: in case someone needed to hear it. A light-blue square annotation highlights forced vulnerability.

“Let’s be honest: I’ve struggled with this too.” It’s a confession with nothing confessed.

Make it extra sloppy: “Sharing this in case someone needed to hear it today.”

Fix: Share the real thing or skip it.

9. Neatly packaged wisdom

LinkedIn post for Whitcombe Pet Grooming, a fictional pet groomer, showing three lessons that are three verbs. A light-blue square annotation highlights packaged wisdom.
Instagram post for Summitline HVAC, a fictional heating and cooling company, showing secrets that are not secrets. A light-blue square annotation highlights packaged wisdom.
X post for Kyle Brandvold, a fictional business coach, showing extra sloppy: the exact framework. A light-blue square annotation highlights packaged wisdom.

“Three lessons that completely changed my perspective.” Get clear. Get focused. Get moving.

Those are three verbs.

Make it extra sloppy: call it “the exact framework.”

Fix: One tip, with the detail that proves you’ve done it.

10. “Drop it below”

X post for Lena Ortega Studio, a fictional design studio, showing a prompt that fits under any post. A light-blue square annotation highlights engagement bait.
LinkedIn post for Achterberg Consulting, a fictional consulting firm, showing the same closer on a leadership post. A light-blue square annotation highlights engagement bait.
Instagram post for Golden Hour Candle Co, a fictional candle maker, showing extra sloppy: three asks in one sentence. A light-blue square annotation highlights engagement bait.

Generic engagement bait. “What’s one thing you’re doing differently?” You could paste this under any post on the internet.

Make it extra sloppy: “Drop a fire emoji if you agree and tag someone who needs to hear this.”

Fix: Ask a question you want the answer to. Or just tell me how to book.

11. The same shape every time

Instagram post for Harbor Lantern Cafe, a fictional cafe, showing three posts, one skeleton. A light-blue square annotation highlights the repeated structure.
X post for Bluebird Print Shop, a fictional print shop, showing hook, points, conclusion, question. A light-blue square annotation highlights the repeated structure.
LinkedIn post for Hartwell Physical Therapy, a fictional physical therapy clinic, showing extra sloppy: the conclusion starts with The takeaway?. A light-blue square annotation highlights the repeated structure.

Hook. Points. Conclusion. Question. New hours? Hook, points, conclusion, question. Holiday closure? Same.

Make it extra sloppy: start the conclusion with “The takeaway?”

Fix: Make the post as long as the news. Some posts are one sentence.

12. Filler hashtags

X post for Maple & Main Hardware, a fictional hardware store, showing three hashtags nobody searches. A light-blue square annotation highlights filler hashtags.
LinkedIn post for Brightwood Window Cleaning, a fictional window cleaning company, showing leadership tags on a scheduling update. A light-blue square annotation highlights filler hashtags.
Instagram post for Roadrunner Tire Co, a fictional tire shop, showing extra sloppy: fifteen of them. A light-blue square annotation highlights filler hashtags.

#Growth #Innovation #Inspiration. Nobody is searching #Growth hoping to find a tire shop.

Make it extra sloppy: fifteen of them.

Fix: Two or three that someone near you would type. Or none.

Again, none of these are bad.

One emoji is fine. So is a short line. People used em dashes long before the robots did. It’s the pile-up that reads as slop.

So before you post, check: could the place across the street post this, word for word? If yes, add one thing only you would know. The street. The Tuesday special. The name of the dog that comes in every morning.

Stop the slop with this prompt

Paste this into whatever robot you’re using before it writes your next caption. Fill in the brackets.

Write (or revise) a social media caption for [business name], a [what the business does] in [neighborhood or city], for [who the customers are]. The post is about [the one thing this post is about]. Here is a real detail to include: [a price, a date, a name, a street, something that happened].

Avoid every one of the following. These are the signs a caption was AI-generated and I don't want any of them.

1. No bullet list unless the content is really a list. If it is, the items do not need to match in length. Never use emoji or icons as bullets.
2. At most one emoji in the whole caption.
3. No em dashes. Use a period or a comma.
4. Write in normal paragraphs, not one sentence per line. No question you answer yourself.
5. No "It's not X, it's Y" or "not X, but Y" lines. State the point directly.
6. No invented epiphany ("I used to think... then I realized"). Do not turn a small update into a life lesson.
7. No scene-setting opener ("In today's fast-paced world..."). The first sentence is the news.
8. No vulnerability or struggle that isn't tied to a real event I gave you. No "Let's be honest."
9. No packaged wisdom: no "three lessons," "the exact framework," or "most people get this wrong." Give one tip and the detail.
10. No generic closing question and no "drop an emoji," "tag someone," or "save this." One call to action, and it is this: [book / call / visit / order].
11. Do not default to hook, points, conclusion, question. Make the caption as long as the news and no longer.
12. No more than three hashtags, none of them generic (#Growth, #Innovation, #Inspiration).

Before you show me anything, check whether a competitor could post your draft unchanged. If so, rewrite it around the real detail. Then list which of these rules your draft breaks and fix them first.

If you need more help, consider booking a consultation meeting with Sister Company and I’ll give you a complimentary audit of your social posts.

I’m just listing my top ones. Want more? Wikipedia’s editors keep a long list of AI writing signs here.

Claude helped me write this post, but the list and opinions are mine. As well as the jokes.

Elena

Sources

Back to Opinions